Is buying a house overrated?

Is Buying A House Overrated?

When it comes to buying a house, gone are the days when it represented the epitome of the American Dream. For years, the amount of renters in America has been increasing.

In my particular case, I prefer to live close to work which is in the heart of Boston. Buying a house or a condo there is just impossible at my current pay grade.

Nevertheless, most people, me included, envision themselves eventually moving to a more affordable area where they can buy a house and build some equity. To do so, a lot of them end up spending way more than they need to. In my opinion, real estate has a weird way of making the outrageous look acceptable.

Part of it is due to the banks using aggressive estimates of what types of mortgages their customers can afford. Part of it is the “keeping up with the Joneses'” mentality that a lot of us experience at some point. But to me, the biggest reason of all is that we don’t think of a house in the same way we do any other purchase or investment. We see it more as a right of passage to adulthood and as a result all rationality is lost in the process.

Some of us see a home as a purchase, some as an investment. I will show you that regardless of what type of homebuyer we are, being careful about how much we spend is a wise decision.

Note: this post is exclusively about primary residences. Rental properties are not part of this analysis.

A house as a purchase, not an investment

If you look at a home as a good you are just buying to achieve a level of comfort or fulfill a certain need, then there is no reason to splurge on it. After all, would you spend a big chunk of your net worth on food, clothes, cars or boats?

The main difference with a home is that it’s generally an appreciating asset. But it’s still important to keep in mind that it’s something we are mostly using for consumption and even if it may be worth a lot money , we don’t actually have easy access to it. We can’t enjoy any of the financial returns of a house unless we sell or rent it.

A house as an investment

Whenever we invest, the first thing we look at is usually what return can be expected based on the history of the asset. The average rate of return on property values is not as well documented as stock market indexes, but it’s clearly a lot lower. Multiple sources cite rates between 3 and 5 %.

Related post:  Money Mistakes Smart People Make

If we throw in maintenance, repairs, insurance and taxes, the return gets even worse.

That’s a relatively lousy investment. Based on these numbers, the best option is to buy the cheapest home that can satisfy our needs and invest the rest in better vehicles.

Real estate investing is a much viable option with rental properties due to the fact that actual income is generated every month.

In addition to the rate of return, we often look for diversification. Buying a house is the real estate version of buying a single stock. Imagine allocating hundreds of thousands of our portfolio – which for most people is a huge percentage – to one company. That’s not even taking into account that most of the investment is financed with debt.

I don’t know but borrowing $200,000 to purchase apple stock while I’m only worth $50,000 doesn’t exactly sound like a smart investment to me.


Part of my strategy for early retirement is eliminating the biggest expense of all: housing. In order to do so, owning my home outright will be the only option. Even though I will almost certainly need to take out a mortgage, I will have to make it a goal of mine to pay it off as soon as possible. The math is simple. If I don’t have a mortgage, my retirement expenses go down dramatically, reducing the amount I need to save by several thousands of dollars.


I am not against buying a house. I actually can’t wait to have my own and stop paying someone else’s mortgage. But when I do take that leap, I will make sure whatever I spend pales in comparison to my net worth. I am not in the habit of overspending on consumer goods or investing in underperforming, under-diversified assets. Why start with my home?

My future house hunting budget won’ t depend on how much I qualify for with the bank or how much money I make. It will solely be a function of how rich or poor I am and how much of my net worth I think should be used towards buying a house. If that results in me leaving Boston for a cheaper area or waiting a few extra years, so be it.

What up?! I go by Mr. Compounding (I know, great name). I grew up in Port-au-Prince, Haiti and moved to Boston after high school. My goal is to share my personal experiences and opinions, as well as encourage people to take control of their finances.

6 thoughts on “Is Buying A House Overrated?

  1. I bought my first house 39 years ago, and have moved twice (both within the same city zone) My house has grown in value, but not to the same level it would have done, if i had moved every few years. As it is, we are happy in our home. yes a better layout would be good, but not enough to move for (and pay lots more money). I did an analysis in November 2016. I am at least £200k better off, because I bought rather than rented, and that is allowing for the opportunity cost of not being able to invest the capital value of the house. So buying was a good move for me.

  2. So many people (including me when I bought) fail to consider maintenance costs when buying. It’s a great call out. That HAS to be part of the math and is a great call out.

    I don’t necessarily regret buying my home, because I still got a great deal. But those endless trips to Home Depot and plumbing calls can add up. I wish I had read some of these articles before making my decision back then. May or may not have changed my mind, but it would have made it a much closer call.

    1. Thanks Adam. My goal was not to discourage buying a house, I myself can’t wait to have one. I just wanted to point out some of the things to keep in mind before making such a big decisions, similar to the ones you spelled out. Thanks for sharing!

  3. Interesting perspective. I think I share similar views on home ownership. To be quite honest, my dream has always been to have a decent size home. I know many people live in small homes and are content but I want to achieve my dreams. I am not talking a 10,000 sq foot mansion, but something large enough to have space.

    The hardest part for me to buy a house is that I want to work in different countries so renting seems like the best option. The only reason for me to buy a home would be to rent it out after a couple years when I move, a possibility that I am heavily considering.

    1. I’m with you on space, which is another reason why it will be too expensive for me to buy in the area I live in now. I am used to a certain level of comfort (not to sound entitled) so living in a tiny home would be difficult.

      Real estate properties are a great investment and I hope I can have some in the future.

      Thanks for your input Stefan!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *